Q: I keep telling my daughter not to judge Christianity by looking at the flawed people who claim Christ. Judge it by going to the source. She says, “God can’t exist because…Who created God?” “How do you know that God is real and not just a bed time story from back in the day?” She is 14.
A: It seems like there are three really big questions wrapped up in this one statement. I will do my best to tackle the 2nd and 3rd ones, knowing that others will be addressing the question of the flawed people in Christianity.
If you have a car in your driveway or garage right now, take a glance at it, or think about it in your mind. Where did it come from? The car dealership, right? Where did they get it from? The auto manufacturer. Where did they get it from? Well, they got the various parts from all over: the tire manufacturer, the seat manufacturer, the glove compartment latch manufacturer, etc. Well, where did they get the materials to make those parts? From all over the place. But eventually, the line of where things come from has to end somewhere. For example, the tire manufacturers are the starting place for the tires. They didn’t get the tires from anywhere else. They created them. But still, they had to get the rubber from somewhere, right. The materials that go into rubber – not sure what those are, exactly – had to come from somewhere.
What I just described with the automobile is the end result in a long line of supply and demand. Someone has a demand for something, and they get it from somewhere. But if you follow that line back long enough, it has to end. Material doesn’t simply start to exist out of nothing. There has to be a First Cause, a being that creates out of nothing. As you look at the universe, it is clear that it had to come from somewhere, from something. The Christian worldview would say that there is a Creator, a God, that created all of it. Many in the scientific world would suggest that there was Big Bang that the universe was created out of; that there was a bunch of gasses that got together, forming a chemical reaction, setting off an explosion, from which the world and everything else in the universe was created (sorry for the simplistic way I stated this – not trying to offend those in the scientific world with the simple explanation; just trying to keep an already long post somewhat short). If that viewpoint is accurate, I have just one question: where did the gasses come from? Didn’t they have to come from somewhere? Matter doesn’t just start to exist, it has to be created. So even if the Big Bang happened like that, there still had to be a Creator that created those gasses. We put a name on that Creator: God.
Let’s dive into the 2nd question, that being the idea that God is a bedtime story. Step outside of Christianity and the Bible for just a moment, and let’s just talk about the generic idea of God. To address this question, I would like you to think about an iPhone. Cool, huh? As you think about an iPhone and all of the things it can do – surf the internet, make a phone call, give directions, play music, take pictures, play movies, make breakfast – you realize that it is a very complex instrument. Something that complex and intricate couldn’t have possibly just come into existence on its own, could it? It’s very evident that there had to be something that made that lovely piece of electronics (can you tell I want one?).
9 comments:
Hey, Fitz
Nice job on explaining this topic. BTW to make rubber, the key ingreadient comes from the gum tree in South America.
JD-
Thanks for the clarification. That has been keeping me up at night. :-)
i wrote a paper last semester on this topic and used I DON'T HAVE ENOUGH FAITH TO BE AN ATHIEST and THE SCIENCE OF GOD as my sources. both of these books are great and i highly recommend them to better understand the answer to this question. but i would like to briefly explain what the books present as the answer to "who created god?" they first explain that before the big bang nothing existed in our universe. the big bang was not just the beginning of space and matter, but also the beginning of TIME! so in other words something had to be created for our universe to exist, GOD created our universe. since time began at the big bang, GOD lives outside of time. he created time therefor is not bound to it. he is limitless and eternal. anything that is eternal has no beginning or end, therefore GOD was not created. he has always existed. again for a better understanding read the books that i had mentioned above. the explain everything in great detail!!
nathan jones
Thanks for your response to this question...Who created God? As a mother of a 6 and 3 year old, you might imagine they have many questions relating to God. My six year old has asked this very same question. As he gets older I'm sure it will come up again. I'm not sure if I gave him the best answer, probably just something like, "God was just always here" (yes- the truth- but at some point he's going to want more of an explanation than that)! Thanks for your insight on this matter!
So the universe is too complex to have happened by chance, but the creator of the universe, which would logically have to be infinately more complex than it's creation, does not have to have a creator. Still sounds like a problem to me.
DWWJ
It's only a problem if you cannot grasp the difference between creator and created. Most intellectual atheists are confounded by this idea since they are committed to 'the material world is the only world', but, alas, creation is different by type than that which creates. In this case "that which is from nothing is by definition the creator." Sorry DWWJ to be so antagonistic, but your weaknesses are the same as ours--your predisposed logic.
VERMEER
to DWWJ, the books i mentioned in my previous comment will help you to understand this problem. but i hope i can maybe clear it up for you. since you are using logic, you realize that there are only two possibilities. either the universe must be eternal or something outside of the universe must be eternal. why? becuase something had to have always existed. something can not come from nothing. since science proves a beginning for the universe, we are only left with the fact that something outside of the universe must be eternal. that something would have to have always existed and would be infinatly powerful to created the universe. as i said before, time began with the beginning of the universe, so God is not bound to it. the concept of time is difficult for us to grasp. scientist have also discovered that time does not pass equally through out our universe. time actually travels faster and slower (than our own time) through out different regions of the universe. so as you may see it is perfectly logical for God to be eternal. i hope this helps, if not please read the books.
Nathan Jones
By definition an eternal being needs no beginning point and, therefore, no creator. Eternal is eternal: no beginning and no end. Everyone agrees the universe had a beginning. One may reject the belief in an eternal, all powerful God but it isn't against logic to postulate such a being. The materialist is still left with the dilemma: who caused the first cause? God, the Author of the Great Story, is outside of time just like an author of a novel is outside of his story.
Post a Comment